Can combined oral therapy improve muscular fitness?

Combined thiazolidinedione–metformin treatment synergistically improves insulin signalling to insulin receptor substrate-1-dependent phosphatidylinositol 3-kinase, atypical protein kinase C and protein kinase B/Akt in human diabetic muscle
Original source: Diabetologia Volume 52, Number 1
Authors: N. Temofonte, M. P. Sajan, S. Nimal, T. Pastoor, C. Fumero, L. Casaubon, J. L. Powe, M. L. Standaert1, and R. V. Farese (corresponding author)
Publication date: January, 2009
DOI (digital document ID): DOI: 10.1007/s00125-008-1180-z
Requires subscription? Yes
Publicly-available abstract: Yes

Synopsis:
Impaired insulin responses in Type 2 diabetes can make it difficult for glucose to get to muscles, where they are needed. It is believed that this is because certain insulin-activated protein enzymes (atypical protein kinase C (aPKC) and protein kinase B (PKB/Akt)) are not as thoroughly activated as they should be. Both metformin and thiazolidinediones (a class of oral diabetes-management drugs that includes rosiglitazone (Avandia) and pioglitazone (Actos)) improve this deficiency. The investigators wanted to know if adding both drugs together would create an even greater improvement.

Combined metformin-thiazolidinedione therapy was administered to Type 2 test ubjects for 5-6 weeks and the results measured. The investigators observed improved glucose movement and improved insulin-induced activity of four muscle signalling factors (insulin receptors plus two protein kinases). Despite this improved activity, the levels of aPKC in muscle tissues were not improved.

Because of the improvement in the four signalling factors, the investigators consider this test successful.

Reliability:
The number of patients tested was not available in the abstract, nor was any CONSORT statement, so it's difficult to tell whether the sample size was large enough to counteract small-sample skew. Several of the investigators are associated with a Veteran's Administration (VA) center. VA patients often get the worst possible levels of care, so it is hard to tell how far along the subjects' T2 had progressed, or how well it had been treated before the test. That we are looking at combined therapy and it is being called "therapeutically useful" even though depressed muscular aPKC levels were not affected by the treatment suggests that this is the sort of experiment that would be funded by a drug manufacturer, with an eye towards pushing more expensive drugs (such as Avandamet, a combination of Avandia and metformin) on the T2 public.

Practical Applications:
Improved muscular uptake of glucose could improve physical performance, and with it, positive incentives toward exercise. This could result in T2 patients being more interested in exercising, and thereby, improving both physical fitness and insulin sensitivity.

This synopsis was based on the abstract only.

On the Low Birth Weight Risk for Insulin Resistance

Altered PI3-Kinase/Akt Signalling in Skeletal Muscle of Young Men with Low Birth Weight
Original source: PLoS ONE 3(11): e3738
Authors: Christine B. Jensen, Malgorzata S. Martin-Gronert, Heidi Storgaard, Sten Madsbad, Allan Vaag, Susan E. Ozanne (corresponding author)
Publication date: November 17, 2008
DOI (digital document ID): 10.1371/journal.pone.0003738
Requires subscription? No
Publicly-available abstract: Yes

Synopsis:
Low birth weight (LBW), an indicator of stress or an adverse fetal environment, is associated with increased future risk of insulin resistance and type 2 diabetes. The investigators are reporting continuing research on a specific insulin signaling pathway may be altered in skeletal muscle of young adult men with LBW. This would help increase our understanding of the mechanisms of insulin resistance in this particular population.

Muscle biopsies were obtained from 20 healthy 19-yr old men who had been in the lowest 10% birth weight for full-term babies and compared them to 20 physically similar men of normal birth weight. The samples were checked for fasting blood glucose and insulin levels, and after four hours in which insulin-production was medically stimulated.

The researchers looked at several previously-unstudied proteins and pathways related to muscular function and muscular glucose metabolism to see if there was any difference between the two groups of men. They found significant differences in the levels of several proteins after insulin stimulation. Some of these differences seen in the LBW group are similar to those seen in patients with insulin-resistant Type 2 diabetes.

The authors conclude that these differences in skeletal-muscle response to insulin precede, and may contribute to, the development of whole-body insulin resistance and type 2 diabetes in men with LBW.


Reliability:
The tests were done on a small number of subjects and a small number of controls. The small sample could skew the results obtained. Also, these were spot observations. Longitudinal observation of these subjects (over a period of time) might give the researchers better information about whether or not insulin resistance progresses in this manner in these subjects.

Practical Applications:
This is one of a series in basic research of how diabetes may develop in specific populations.

In many areas, low birth weight is associated with maternal malnutrition and/or poor prenatal care -- which are further associated with low-income communities and minority communities. Type 2 diabetes is more common in these groups than in the general population. Proving a definite link and path may bring more interest in providing education, and medical and dietary services, to this high-risk group.

Ethics note:
Written informed consent was provided from all participants and approval was obtained from the regional ethics committee.

This synopsis was based on the entire article.